I read the whole AnimeX Workmanship Judging brouhaha, and I was totally
appalled. This February I convinced the masquerade directors of
Katsucon to let me be the workmanship judge. I spent the first part of
the day wandering the con in rather mundane clothing (o.k. I was wearing
one of my bat belt buckles and a bat embroidered shirt) and got no
negative vibes at all. I spent the rest of the day except for a 1 hour
dinner break doing workmanship judging. (Approximately 70 costumes.) I
was still judging right through the cosplay. Everybody who wanted
workmanship judging got it, up close and personal, and I even sent a
couple of entrants out to bring me reference materials for their
costumes and then made the comparisons. While the other judges were
hassling, I got to present the workmanship awards, explaining to the
audience why I made the awards I did and invited them to take a closer
look if they had the opportunity.
I must have done something right, because I got three letters thanking
me for my judging. (2 from competitors and one from an audience member
who had not competed) I also got a complementary paragraph from Kevin
Lillard in the April Animerica, and I’m told, some complementary press
in a couple of the anime web groups. I hope to be asked back next year,
and if I am I’ll bring some more organization to the workmanship judging.
Almost any of us on this list and probably the ICGD list can judge
workmanship. You don’t have to be familiar with the character to see if
seams are straight and the hems finished, and if the contestant brings
documentation you can judge accuracy in recreation. (BTW there was one
young lady there who can give Dany a run for her money on
documentation.) I was promoting Balticon, but if I am asked back next
year I’ll push the CC’s because Kastsucon drew people from all over the
country. If we really want to make inroads in this community I’d like
to suggest that each year’s CC might consider giving a free membership
to “best novice” (or whatever the con calls the equivalent.) at several
of the larger Anime Cons. This not only gives us the chance to promote
Costume Con, but also sends a loud and clear message that we want them.
Andy, please tell Karisu-sama for me that I would love to have had the
opportunity to judge her daughters’ costumes and give them the respect
that they deserved.
Marty
Andrew T Trembley wrote:
>Took a few days to get permission to forward this
>
>Begin forwarded message:
>
>
>>From: Karisu-sama <chris@imagecraft.com>
>>Date: July 8, 2004 3:51:19 AM PDT
>>To: Andrew Trembley <attrembl@bovil.com>, kevin@twistedimage.com
>>Cc: Richard Man <richard@imagecraft.com>
>>Subject: Costume Con, Anime Expo, and so forth….
>>
>>Heyo, guys! Pieces of news and sundry… Forgive me if I’m writing
>>very incoherently – I am very tired and totally brain-fried….
>>
>>~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
>>1) I am becoming more and more enthusiastic about working with y’all
>>for the hopeful Costume Con 2008. To this end I have been dropping
>>info about it all over the place in the Anime cosplay community, in
>>order to draw as many of the people as I know in cosplay to Costume
>>Con (and I know a LOT of people in that community.) As a ‘crossover
>>costumer” myself, I really would like to see a harmony of the various
>>costuming communities, not entirely separate worlds that never meet…
>>
>>In addition, as a Cosplay.Com staffer, I get to hang out with with the
>>”big names”, and I have been heavily promoting Costume Con to the best
>>of my ability among the top-level cosplayers that I know, such as Yaya
>>Han, Justin, Rosiel, Tristin Citrine, Lily and Haruka, Hoshikage, and
>>so forth. These are Master-class people. Several of them wish to
>>branch out into original design costuming (or already do so). Their
>>work is incredible. Yaya (who is a very nice person) has been asked
>>”not to participate” in several Masquerades because she is “unfair
>>competition”. I told her she really ought to take her work to Costume
>>Con. She didn’t even know it was in Atlanta this past year – her home
>>town!
>>
>>I personally feel that people like this ought to be brought to Costume
>>Con and get in with the ICG. Justin, for example, told me that he’s
>>hardly even heard about the ICG, and has no idea how to join. I think
>>we ought to really try to embrace this incredibly talented and
>>seriously-costuming young generation. New blood, new blood! 😀
>>
>>One issue that will have to be addressed with them is registration
>>fees – these Anime-con-raised kids are used to paying $50 tops –
>>anything more is exorbitant to them, and will take a lot of
>>explanation justifying why there is a higher cost (and it would help
>>if they know about the early fees before they go up!) I have explained
>>that Worldcons, for example, really DO give you the”bang” for the
>>incredible buck, but they are young, and not so used to cons “by fans
>>for fans”….
>>
>>~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
>>2) Some of this determination of mine is further prompted by the utter
>>debacle known as the Anime Expo 2004 Masquerade Workmanship “Judging”,
>>at which my children ATTEMPTED to debut their first-ever self-made
>>costume set. (I say ATTEMPTED, because we ended up withdrawing due to
>>the extreme offensiveness of the way we were treated.) Gods, do we
>>NEED better judged and better run cons at Anime Masquerades. I for one
>>would like to promote a LOT more big-name cosplayer pressure on Con
>>staff for ICG-style Masqs. For this, or course, we need to get more
>>cosplayers in the ICG…
>>
>>If you have any time to read about the AX’04 Masq., the whole sordid
>>mess is detailed in this Cosplay.Com thread:
>>http://forums.cosplay.com/showthread.php?t=38702
>>
>>If you don’t have much time, at least perhaps try page 1, and here are
>>a couple of the pages where I am in the discussion, if you care to
>>scroll to my posts:
>>http://forums.cosplay.com/showthread.php?t=38702&page=3&pp=15
>>http://forums.cosplay.com/showthread.php?t=38702&page=5&pp=15
>>
>>In any case, the entire situation was absolutely disgusting,
>>especially after how incredibly well things were done last year,
>>
>>My KIDS, 13 and 9, who busted their butts over their workmanship (and
>>the youngest spent time in the emergency room for sewing through her
>>finger with the machine) have been absolutely insulted and demeaned.
>>(Plucky them, they are improving on their entry and taking it to
>>Worldcon instead.) I am incensed.
>>
>>~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
>>3) I’ve been costuming for 31 years. How the heck can I get some
>>experience judging? It would give me more clout among these people
>>almost half my age, many of whom already have quite a bit of judging
>>experience. I’d be happy to do an apprenticeship or something…. I
>>just have never done judging before.
>>
>>~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
>>Anyway, thanks for putting up with my rambling. Gotta go crash now.
>>See you soon somewhere, hopefully. (Worldcon?) *hugs*
>>
>>
>>– Karisu-sama (Chris)
>>———————————-
>> Moero!!
>>
>>
>>
>>
|
|